Can a company recover a competition fine from its director, and potentially from the D&O insurer?
-
Insight Article 12 November 2026 12 November 2026
-
UK & Europe
-
Regulatory movement
Who ultimately bears the cost when an undertaking is fined for an infringement of competition law: the undertaking itself, the responsible director, or the director’s D&O insurer?
In a recent opinion before the Court of Justice of the European Union, Advocate General Szpunar indicates that EU competition law may preclude an undertaking from passing the financial burden of its own infringement on to a director. The Court’s forthcoming judgment may therefore have far-reaching consequences for directors’ liability, D&O coverage and potentially even the recovery of other administrative fines in the Netherlands.
Below, we discuss the significance of the German judgments and Advocate General Szpunar’s Opinion for the development of Dutch law. We also consider the current position in the Netherlands regarding the recovery of administrative fines from a director who is liable.
Opinion of Advocate General Szpunar in the Zapp case
In Germany, the Regional Court of Saarbrücken, the Regional Court of Düsseldorf and the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf held that a competition fine imposed on a undertaking cannot be recovered from a director. In the subsequent proceedings, the Federal Court of Justice referred the following question to the Court of Justice of the European Union for a preliminary ruling:
“Does Article 101 TFEU preclude a provision in national law under which a legal person on which a national competition authority has imposed a fine for an infringement of Article 101 TFEU committed by its management body may claim compensation from the management body for the damage the legal person has suffered as a result?”
Advocate General Szpunar concludes that Article 101 TFEU, which prohibits cartels, precludes the recovery of a competition fine from a director:
“(…) Article 101 TFEU must be interpreted as precluding an undertaking, on which a fine for infringement of that provision has been imposed, from seeking compensation from a member of its management body for the financial loss resulting exclusively from the payment of that fine”
This applies even if German company law would permit such a recourse claim. EU law is decisive in this respect. Otherwise, the effectiveness, or effet utile, of the EU system of fines would be undermined. According to the Advocate General, the possibility that the director may be covered for such a claim under a D&O policy reinforces the concern that the undertaking would ultimately not bear the economic burden of the fine itself. After all, if the legal entity can pass the competition fine on to the director and the director can claim coverage under a D&O policy, the insurer, rather than the infringer, ultimately bears the fine.
The Advocate General bases this conclusion on three principal arguments:
The undertaking is itself the infringer. Under competition law, the undertaking, as an economic unit, is the party that infringes the prohibition and the party on which the fine is imposed. It therefore cannot be both the infringer and the injured party.
Article 101 TFEU does not protect the undertaking. That provision protects competition and the internal market. It does not protect the assets of a undertaking fined for its own infringement.
Recourse undermines the deterrent effect of the fine. Competition fines must be effective, proportionate and deterrent. That deterrent effect is weakened if the undertaking passes the financial burden on to a director, with the result that the burden may ultimately fall on the D&O insurer.
Advocate General Szpunar’s Opinion concerns loss consisting of the amount of the competition fine paid. The Advocate General does not expressly address other heads of loss, such as investigation, defence and compliance costs.
The significance of the Opinion for the development of Dutch law
If the Court of Justice follows the Advocate General’s Opinion, this will provide important guidance on the operation of EU law and its consequences for undertakings and their directors. The contours of the answer to the question of which competition and other fines an undertaking may seek to pass on are therefore beginning to emerge. We explain this below.
1. Recovery may be permitted where the fine remains unpaid in insolvency
In the Netherlands, the Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal held, in the particular circumstances of Heiploeg’s insolvency, that a recourse claim against a former director was not contrary to the effectiveness of Article 101 TFEU. In the well-known Heiploeg case, a former director had entered into prohibited price-fixing arrangements on behalf of the legal entity. This resulted in an EU competition fine of EUR 27 million. Heiploeg was unable to pay the fine, which contributed to its insolvency. The insolvency trustees subsequently held the director liable under Article 2:9 of the Dutch Civil Code for improper performance of his duties and claimed damages equal to the amount of the fine.
The director relied, among other things, on EU competition law. In his view, that law precluded the fine from being passed on to him through a damages claim. Referring to the above-mentioned judgment of the Regional Court of Saarbrücken, the Court of Appeal acknowledged that the effectiveness of Article 101 TFEU raises the question whether a legal entity may bring such a recourse claim. However, it did not answer that question because of the particular circumstances of the Heiploeg case.
The legal entity was not seeking to recover a fine it had paid, as had been the case before the Regional Court of Saarbrücken. On the contrary, it had been unable to pay the fine. As a result of the insolvency, the economic burden of the fine fell on the body of creditors. The insolvency trustees brought the claim for the benefit of the insolvent estate and therefore acted in the interests of the creditors. In those circumstances, the Court of Appeal held that the claim was not contrary to the effectiveness of Article 101 TFEU. The decisive factor was that, because the fine had not been paid and the company was insolvent, its economic burden fell not on the undertaking but on its creditors as a whole. The Court of Appeal therefore held:
“In the Court of Appeal’s view, the recourse claim brought by the insolvency trustees is therefore not incompatible with the interpretation of EU law adopted by the German court.”
2. Recovery from a subsidiary outside insolvency is generally not permitted
In April 2026, in Bencis/Dossche, the Dutch Supreme Court upheld the judgment of The Hague Court of Appeal in a case concerning the recovery of competition fines outside insolvency. The case concerned a parent company on which a competition fine had been imposed for infringements committed by a former subsidiary. The parent argued that it had been unaware of the subsidiary’s conduct and that the subsidiary had therefore acted unlawfully towards it. On that basis, the subsidiary was said to be liable for the fine imposed on the parent company.
The Dutch Supreme Court held:
“An infringement of competition law by a subsidiary is not, without more, unlawful towards its parent company, even if the parent company was unaware of the infringement. Additional circumstances may render the subsidiary’s conduct unlawful towards the parent company, for example where the subsidiary deliberately misled the parent or deliberately kept it unaware of the infringement of competition law.”
The judgment does not establish that recovery from a subsidiary is categorically excluded. However, a competition law infringement by a subsidiary is not, without more, unlawful towards its parent company. A successful claim requires additional circumstances justifying a different outcome.
3. Recovery from a director outside insolvency is probably not permitted
Dutch case law has not yet determined whether a legal entity may, outside insolvency, pass a fine on to its director. The Advocate General’s Opinion before the Court of Justice is directly relevant to this situation. If the Court follows the Opinion, a legal entity will, in principle, be unable to recover a paid fine from its director as damages outside insolvency. The undertaking is itself the infringer and the addressee of the fine, so the economic burden must remain with it. A further argument is that an undertaking will generally have benefited from the prohibited price-fixing arrangements. The fine is intended to have a deterrent effect, and the benefit obtained by the legal entity may be taken into account when determining its amount.
The Opinion also leaves room for debate about other heads of loss. Debate may likewise remain possible where the director has acted unlawfully towards the legal entity independently of, and separately from, the competition law infringement.
Significance for D&O insurers
For D&O insurers, this approach is relevant to both coverage and claims handling. If the Court follows the Opinion, an undertaking will, in principle, be unable to pass the fine on through a liability claim against its director and, by extension, to the D&O insurer. The economic burden of the fine will therefore remain with the infringer.
Even if the Court follows it, the Opinion does not necessarily mean that none of the claims connected with the infringement may be recovered from the director. The Advocate General expressly limits his answer to the financial loss arising solely from payment of the fine. Debate therefore remains possible regarding other heads of loss, such as investigation, defence and compliance costs. Given the direct connection between those costs, the infringement of the competition rules and the resulting fine, it cannot be ruled out that recovery of certain costs may likewise encounter objections under EU law.
The position becomes more interesting in relation to follow-on damages claims, which often arise after a fine has been imposed. Such claims fall outside the scope of the Opinion. For those claims, the nature of the duty breached by the director remains relevant. The insurability and coverage of such heads of loss must be assessed separately by reference to the applicable law and the specific policy wording. Moreover, follow-on claims concern loss suffered by third parties as a result of the competition law infringement, rather than recovery of the fine imposed on the undertaking itself. The EU law objections to passing on the fine therefore do not automatically apply to such claims.
Finally, the Court of Justice’s eventual judgment may also have implications beyond competition law, such as for sanctions in the fields of data protection, ESG regulation and administrative sanctions more broadly. Those areas may also involve fines that are similar in nature to the competition fines discussed here. For now, however, this is a potential broader effect on legal practice that we have identified if the Court follows the Opinion, rather than a conclusion reached by the Advocate General. Time will tell.
End

