Sharjah Court of Cassation upholds DIFC Courts jurisdiction clause in insurance dispute

  • Legal Development 17 November 2026 17 November 2026
  • Middle East

  • Regulatory movement

  • Insurance

Leonard Soudagar, Robert James and Shadi Kousa of Clyde & Co, and Faisal Al Hamzi of Al Sahlawi & Co, acted for the successful insurer.

In recent years, we have seen an increase in significant insurance disputes leading to jurisdictional challenges in the UAE. There are many reasons for this. They include inconsistencies within the policy’s terms and conditions, and documentation, the jurisdictional gateways under federal law and the laws of the Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC) and Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM), and the requirement for an insured to first bring a claim before Sanadak and the UAE Central Bank’s Insurance Dispute Resolution Committee (IDRC). 

Article 148 of Federal Decree-Law No. 6 of 2025 Regarding the Central Bank, Regulation of Financial Institutions and Activities, and Insurance Business (the Insurance Law) provides for the establishment within Sanadak of one or more committees to determine disputes arising from licensed banking and insurance activities. According to Article 4 of the Insurance Authority Board Resolution No. 33 of 2019 concerning the Regulation of the Committees for the Settlement and Resolution of Insurance Disputes (the IA Resolution), “The Committees shall be competent to settle and resolve Insurance Disputes of all types and classes of insurance arising from the complaints of the Insured, the Beneficiaries or the affected of capacity or interest in the Insurance Dispute against the Company only of any value whatsoever, whether estimated or not.”

In practice, Sanadak requires the policyholder first to have made an official complaint to the insurer and, generally, to allow 15 calendar days for the insurer to respond. If no written response is provided within that period, or the policyholder is dissatisfied with the response, the complaint may be escalated through Sanadak and, where appropriate, referred to the IDRC for determination.

Decisions of the IDRC are subject to the appeal regime prescribed by Article 148 of the Insurance Law. For disputes exceeding AED 100,000, the IDRC’s decision may be challenged before the competent Court of Appeal within 30 days. 

There has, therefore, been a debate about whether a jurisdiction clause in an insurance policy in the UAE which provides for the Courts of the DIFC or the ADGM would be enforceable, particularly as against a policyholder where there is no connection to those respective jurisdictions. This is to be distinguished from arbitration agreements because there is a carve-out in Article 5(3) of the IA Resolution, which provides that the IDRC cannot hear disputes that are subject to an arbitration agreement.

As we reported on 3 February 2026, the IDRC upheld an exclusive DIFC Courts jurisdiction clause earlier this year and refused to hear the policyholder’s complaint. The IDRC held that “the insurance policy submitted in the dispute established that the parties agreed that the DIFC Courts would have jurisdiction over any dispute arising from the policy or relating to its interpretation or performance; accordingly, any judicial dispute or claim between the parties concerning the policy fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of the DIFC Courts”.

We can now report that the policyholder’s appeals to the Sharjah Court of Appeal, and subsequently to the Sharjah Court of Cassation, have been dismissed. In short, they found that the policyholder did not discharge the burden of proof as it had sought to rely, effectively, on general principles and not on the wording of the insurance policy which it failed to put before the appeal courts (presumably on the basis that it included an express agreement to refer all disputes to the DIFC Courts). 

This case supports the position that an exclusive jurisdiction clause in favour of the DIFC Courts, and logically the ADGM Courts, in insurance policies issued in the UAE is permissible and will be enforced by the ‘onshore’ UAE Courts. 

The key takeaway is that the issue of jurisdiction in UAE insurance disputes is far from straightforward and regularly leads to major disputes and satellite or parallel litigation. It is crucial to give thought to this issue on entering into the policy and when devising any claim strategy. There are pros and cons to having insurance disputes heard either in the civil law or common law courts of the UAE, or in arbitration. It may sound obvious, but it is essential to ensure that the forum is very clearly expressed within the policy (it is not always, and there is scope for competing interpretations and inconsistency with the relevant legislation) and to ensure that claims are advanced in the correct forum (they are not always, as this case demonstrates). 

Should you have any questions, please do contact Leonard Soudagar, Robert James or Shadi Kousa, or your usual Clyde & Co contact. 

End

Stay up to date with Clyde & Co

Sign up to receive email updates straight to your inbox!