Week 1 - Victorian Royal Commission into the Construction Sector - The Commission's emerging focus: implications for industry participants

  • Insight Article 18 November 2026 18 November 2026
  • Asia Pacific

  • Victorian Royal Commission

The first substantive hearing block of the Royal Commission into the Integrity of Major Public and Civil Infrastructure Construction Projects in Victoria commenced on 9 November 2026. The opening week has provided the clearest indication to date of how the Commission intends to examine conduct on major Victorian infrastructure projects and the governance, contractual and oversight arrangements within which that conduct occurred.

A significant focus has been the Gap Road level crossing removal project at Sunbury, part of Victoria's Level Crossing Removal Program. The Commission is examining events surrounding a work stoppage during a major rail occupation in June 2022, the circumstances in which work resumed, the arrangements that followed, their financial consequences, and what relevant State entities and project participants knew and did.

Importantly, the Commission's examination is not confined to the industrial dispute. It is testing the contractual and governance framework surrounding the project: who had authority to act, the basis for asserted safety or industrial concerns, what contractual and operational alternatives were available, how decisions were documented and escalated, and how resulting costs were allocated and ultimately borne.  The Commission has not made findings in relation to the Gap Road case study. Allegations, evidence, submissions and propositions advanced during the hearings should not be treated as established facts or findings of misconduct. The evidence remains ongoing and subject to challenge.

Subject to that qualification, the opening week points to a broader inquiry into the intersection between industrial relations, workplace safety, contractual rights, procurement, project delivery, financial accountability and government oversight. The recurring questions are practical: who knew, who decided, what authority they had, what alternatives were considered, what the contemporaneous record shows and who ultimately bore the cost.

Key points for organisations

  • Decision-making and accountability: who knew, who decided, what authority they had and what was escalated.
  • Contemporaneous evidence: whether the documentary record supports later accounts of why material decisions were made.
  • Safety and industrial relations: whether safety and right-of-entry processes can be clearly distinguished from parallel industrial issues.
  • Procurement and cost: why providers or arrangements changed, how replacements were selected, what the change cost and where that cost ultimately fell.
  • Witness evidence: whether witnesses can distinguish genuine recollection from refreshed recollection, usual practice, inference and reconstruction from documents.
  • Commission process: whether document searches, production, redaction and any withholding of material comply with the Commission's statutory framework and procedures.

The Commission’s inquiry is broader than individual conduct

The Commission was established under section 5 of the Inquiries Act 2014 (Vic). Its Terms of Reference extend beyond allegations of corruption, criminal conduct and serious misconduct. They encompass the operational, contractual, regulatory, statutory and cultural conditions associated with such conduct, together with State oversight, systemic causes and preconditions, procurement, impacts on project cost and delivery, and the adequacy of government and industry responses.

That breadth is apparent in the opening hearings. Labels such as ‘safety issue’, ‘industrial matter’ or ‘best for project’ have not ended the inquiry. The Commission’s questioning has instead sought to separate what occurred, the power or authority relied upon, the stated reason for the action, its practical effect, its commercial or industrial consequences and the resulting cost.  Counsel Assisting has indicated that the Gap Road case study is not an exercise in determining civil or criminal liability. The Commission may ultimately make findings within its Terms of Reference, including adverse findings where the applicable statutory and procedural fairness requirements are satisfied. No such findings have been made in relation to Gap Road.

Knowledge, authority and escalation are central

A recurring feature of the questioning has been an effort to establish who knew what, when they knew it, where the information came from and who had authority to act. Witnesses have been taken to reporting lines, delegations, alliance governance arrangements and decision-making requirements. The treatment of industrial relations risk within the alliance has also prompted examination of the respective roles of contractors, alliance participants and the State.

The distinction between formal authority and practical influence is important. Where information passed through several people, the questioning has separated what was actually said, its original source, what recipients understood or assumed and what was subsequently done. Programme or delivery pressure will not necessarily answer questions about the alternatives considered, the approving authority or the contractual mechanism relied upon.

Contemporaneous records will matter

The events under examination occurred more than four years ago. The Commission has therefore closely tested the quality and source of witness recollection. Its questioning has distinguished actual recollection from memory refreshed by documents, usual practice, inference and assumption. Emails, messages, handwritten notes, site diaries, WorkSafe material, entry records, risk assessments, procurement documents and invoices have formed part of that exercise.

A contemporaneous document may support an account without establishing that a witness independently remembers the event. Equally, evidence of usual practice does not establish what occurred on a particular occasion.

Where contemporaneous records are incomplete, oral evidence and surrounding circumstances assume greater significance. Differences between operational records and reports prepared for executives or government may also attract scrutiny.

Safety and right-of-entry issues are being tested by purpose and effect

The Commission’s questioning has not been confined to whether a safety concern existed. It has examined the concern identified and the contemporaneous information supporting it, the statutory or site authority relied upon, who could direct work to cease, the practical effect of conduct where no formal cessation power was exercised, and what subsequently caused work or entry arrangements to change. This reflects the distinction in the Terms of Reference between legitimate occupational health and safety activity and allegations that safety or right-of-entry mechanisms may have been used for an industrial purpose.

The distinction matters. The existence of an industrial dispute does not, of itself, make a safety concern illegitimate. Equally, describing an issue as one of safety does not necessarily determine its legal character, purpose or effect.

The Commission is following the money

The Gap Road evidence demonstrates the level of commercial detail that may be examined when industrial or delivery pressures result in changes to project arrangements. The Commission is examining former and replacement arrangements, workforce composition, enterprise agreement settings, rates and mark-ups, procurement processes, invoices and contractual allocation of cost. The alliance’s cost and governance arrangements are also being examined in the context of decisions made under significant programme pressure.

The broader point for project participants is that commercial consequences may form an important part of the evidentiary picture. A decision taken to maintain delivery may be examined not only by reference to why it was made, but also who approved it, what alternatives were available, how any new provider or arrangement was selected, what it cost and who ultimately paid.

Compulsory process creates a separate risk

The opening week also demonstrated that compliance with the Commission’s compulsory processes can itself attract scrutiny, independently of the underlying conduct under investigation.

On 12 November, Counsel Assisting raised concerns publicly about the timing and completeness of document production by the Victorian Infrastructure Delivery Authority, including handwritten notes said to have been caught by earlier notices to produce and hard redactions said not to comply with the Commission’s document production protocol. Counsel Assisting also identified material said to be directly relevant to the Gap Road inquiry that had initially been redacted and referred to other potentially responsive material that had only recently been identified or produced.

The Commissioner observed that the late provision of information had disrupted the Commission’s investigation and pursuit of lines of inquiry. He subsequently emphasised the importance of early, genuine and comprehensive disclosure and suggested that, where a recipient is genuinely uncertain whether information or a document should be disclosed, that uncertainty will generally favour disclosure.

Those observations must be understood in the context of the Commission’s particular statutory framework. The Inquiries Act 2014 (Vic), the terms of any compulsory notice, the Commission’s applicable practice directions and protocols, and any relevant confidentiality or non-publication orders should be considered carefully when responding to compulsory process.

Questions concerning privilege, confidentiality, redaction or other restrictions on production or publication should be identified early and addressed under the applicable statutory and procedural framework. These issues should not be resolved by applying ordinary litigation practices without considering the particular requirements.

What this means for organisations: Treat a compulsory notice as a legal and evidence-management exercise from the outset. Identify custodians and data sources, preserve potentially responsive material, document the search methodology and quality assurance process, and escalate questions of scope, privilege, confidentiality, redaction or production before the applicable deadline.

What organisations should do now

  1. Preserve and map records. Identify project files, contract and procurement systems, site diaries, safety records, invoices, handwritten notes and relevant electronic communications, including informal channels where properly within scope.
  2. Map decision rights. Identify operational, project, alliance, corporate and government reporting lines, together with the delegations and contractual authorities applying to material decisions.
  3. Reconstruct significant decisions. Test the chronology against contemporaneous documents: who decided, their authority, the alternatives considered, legal advice obtained, commercial consequences and escalation.
  4. Prepare witnesses carefully. Ensure witnesses distinguish genuine recollection from refreshed recollection, ordinary practice, inference and assumption.
  5. Review commercial changes made under pressure. Examine sole-source appointments, labour-hire and traffic-management changes, rate movements, invoice controls, variations and contractual cost recovery.
  6. Review safety and industrial interfaces. Confirm who may direct work to cease, how right-of-entry events are recorded, how regulators are engaged, how rectification is documented and who has authority to recommence work.
  7. Review Commission-readiness protocols. Ensure legal, investigation and information-management teams understand the Commission’s statutory powers, practice directions, production requirements, confidentiality arrangements and applicable non-publication orders.
  8. Align legal and communications teams. Public statements should distinguish clearly between allegation, evidence, submission and finding. Material subject to a non-publication order or other restriction must not be published.

Looking ahead

The opening week suggests that the Commission’s analysis will extend across people, powers, records, contracts and public money.  For construction and infrastructure participants, the significance is broader than the particular allegations being examined. Governance arrangements, delegations, escalation, reporting, record-keeping and the evidentiary basis for decisions made under pressure may all inform the Commission’s consideration of systemic issues and possible reform.

The immediate priority is evidence readiness. Organisations should preserve the complete record, identify decision rights and test their understanding of significant events against contemporaneous material before responding to compulsory process or preparing witnesses.

Resource Hub

This article forms part of our broader Royal Commission Readiness series. For further analysis, practical guidance and updates as the Commission’s work develops, visit our Royal Commission Resource Hub, which brings together our latest legal insights and resources. You can also listen to our Royal Commission Readiness podcast series, where we examine the key legal, regulatory and practical issues arising from the Commission and what they mean for organisations, boards and individuals involved in major infrastructure and construction projects.

This publication provides a general summary of public hearing material as at 16 November 2026. It is not legal advice. The evidence is ongoing, further evidence may be received and the Commission has not made findings on the Gap Road case study. Nothing in this update should be understood as expressing a view that any person or organisation has engaged in unlawful conduct, corruption, criminal conduct, serious misconduct or other wrongdoing.

End

Stay up to date with Clyde & Co

Sign up to receive email updates straight to your inbox!

Victorian Royal Commission into the Construction Sector: Readiness & Resource Hub

Read More