Singapore’s First Published Employment Claims Tribunals’ Decision on Wrongful Dismissal – JGP v JGQ [2026] SGECT 1
-
Bulletin 19 novembre 2026 19 novembre 2026
-
Asie-Pacifique
-
Défis humains
-
Emploi, pensions et immigration
The Employment Claims Tribunals ("ECT") has recently begun publishing written grounds of decision in selected employment disputes. These decisions provide useful insight into how the ECT is approaching employment claims in practice.
In this first update, we look at JGP v JGQ [2026] SGECT 1, the ECT's first published decision concerning wrongful dismissal claim following an investigation into employee medical-benefit claims.
Key takeaway: A fair disciplinary process does not, by itself, establish just cause or excuse for dismissal. If an employer relies on dishonesty, wilfulness or intentional misconduct, it should ensure there is evidence supporting that allegation and not merely evidence of a policy breach. Employers should also consider whether dismissal is proportionate and consistent with the treatment of employees in comparable cases.
What happened?
The employee submitted numerous claims for reimbursement of items including vitamins, supplements and skincare products under her employer's medical benefits policy. Following an investigation and disciplinary inquiry, the employer concluded that she had committed serious breaches of the policy intentionally and dishonestly.
Although the disciplinary committee initially recommended a warning together with a 100% reduction of her performance bonus, the recommendation was subsequently reconsidered and revised to termination. The employee was given contractual notice, part of which was later converted into salary in lieu.
What did the ECT decide?
The ECT found that the employee had been dismissed without just cause or excuse.
Importantly, the ECT accepted that the employer had conducted a "due inquiry" and had given the employee a fair opportunity to respond. The problem was therefore not principally the disciplinary process. It was whether the employer had proved the grounds on which it relied for dismissal.
The ECT was not satisfied that the evidence established dishonesty, recklessness or wilful blindness. Although the employee had made impermissible claims, the evidence was also consistent with a broader workplace misunderstanding about what could be claimed. There was no evidence, for example, that the employee had received and ignored a warning, acknowledged relevant training or attempted to conceal her conduct.
The ECT instead found that the employee had been negligent in submitting impermissible claims. In the circumstances, including her junior position, clean record and the treatment of other employees with broadly comparable conduct, that lesser wrongdoing did not amount to just cause or excuse for dismissal.
The ECT also held that where an employer relies on misconduct as the basis for dismissal, the requirement for a due inquiry applies even where the employee is terminated with notice or salary in lieu.
The employee was awarded S$12,999 for loss of income and S$4,333 for harm. Her separate claim for a 2023 performance bonus was dismissed.
What should employers take away?
- Be precise about allegations: Avoid characterising conduct as dishonest, fraudulent or wilful unless there is sufficient evidence supporting the employee's state of mind.
- Investigate fairly and document the reasoning: Employees should understand the allegations against them, be given a proper opportunity to respond, and the employer should document why the evidence supports its eventual findings.
- Consider proportionality: A policy breach does not necessarily mean that dismissal is the appropriate sanction. The seriousness of the conduct and the surrounding circumstances should be considered.
- Treat comparable cases consistently: Where employees involved in similar conduct receive different sanctions, employers should be able to explain the objective reasons for that difference.
A copy of the judgement can be found here.
Note: The judgment records that the employer had filed applications seeking leave to appeal in the related cases. We are not aware of any published appellate decision as at the date of this update.
Fin


